Inside is totally different...

I am a student at Hull School of Art and Design, This blog will form part of my portfolio of work required for interactive communication, with a focus first semester on - What makes good design? This will manifest itself through a series of reviews.

Saturday, 29 October 2011

What makes good design?: Toonlet.com

Criteria of evaluation: (human-computer interaction, user interface design, usability, information design, audience targeting and suitability) 
The site essentially allows you to create a comic online - or a webcomic, the site also acts as a blogging tool. The  software used for creating a comic left me somewhat wanting more. You are limited to one character per panel, one speech bubble and a box that can be used for describing location or other such contextual information. I found that upon writing large amounts of text there were issues with how small the character became. You can choose from pre-constructed characters or create your own from scratch, using a selection of anatomical parts, provided by different artists. The process of creating your own character and was extremely rewarding and enjoyable, however this was somewhat negated by the fact that the software is limiting and somewhat restrictive. There were also a few issues with characters being lost or deleted without cause and trouble accessing the site. 

An Example comic stip


In terms of the interface, after a few minutes playing around with the 'create a comic' element, all was pretty clear. The fact that the comic is kept quite simple means it is easy to pick up and relatively quick to complete. Other then a few problems encountered with loosing characters the site itself was well laid out easy to navigate and entertaining.

My comic strip - as you can see the text has begun to over lap my characters


The sites target in my opinion is quite broad, anyone who wishes to show their creativity or whit might enjoy the site. It would seemingly not appeal to any one with a real interest in comics or artists sue to the limitations, drawing a comic would be quicker and has the added bonus of unlimited freedoms.  

Wednesday, 26 October 2011

5* review: Kongregate

(Criteria of evaluation: human-computer interaction, user interface design, usability, information design, audience targeting and suitability)


A website I frequently use, and which I feel has good design is http://www.kongregate.com/. The website is for casual games, hosting a huge selection. The site also incorporates an account system which includes achievements, friends lists and  a leveling feature. One negative is that the not all the games include achievements, which can be an issues for more competitive players. 


The website has a clear target audience of people who do game and are relatively serious gamers this is evident from the nature of a some of the games. 'Spin offs' from less casual console or PC games are popular. As well as games that are only real cater to people from a gaming background, due to certain aspects and language of the games. 


There is an easy to use rating system for games and within each game there are chat windows to converse within each game. This along with other factors such as the leader boards and push towards multilayer games give the site a clear community focus. The menus are easy to navigate, searching for a new game is simple sue to the clear categories and refianble search.


Finally, the site is naturally kept frequently updated, with a featured games widget fixed to the dashboard. Occasional emails informing of new games helps keep players coming back and stay informed.


All in all I would award Kongregate